Finance

‘Greed didn’t go green’: Can Islamic finance reconcile its ambitions with its oil wealth?

Bandipur National Park wildfire 2019. [WikiMedia/NaveenNkadalaveni]

If you had ₹100 crore to invest, would climate change matter? In this thought-provoking piece, the author asks how climate finance is changing the way banks, investors and economies think about money, risk and the future of the planet.

Some time ago, while discussing climate change, I was asked about climate finance, probably because I have been a banker for most of my working life. My answer was vague and ambiguous.

In fact, I am embarrassed to acknowledge that I have never thought about it much. So, I said it has something to do with the environment and climate change; that’s it.

However, I was bothered by another question that I put to particularly no one.

How does an economy that’s basically exploitative and extractive by design suddenly start to care about the planet?

After all, the world, as we see it, functions at the cost paid by the damage it does to the environment.

Anyway, I asked AI, because that’s what we all do now, isn’t it? Surprisingly, it responded with a question.

“Suppose I gave you ₹100 crore to invest. Would climate change decide where you put that money?”

Suddenly, my perspective on answering my own question changed and I thought about it the way I never had.

I’d put climate change in a box. Floods, weather changes, all that. Not money, not investing.

But then when you actually think about it, it makes itself obvious and you can’t help but realise – if climate change changes what is and what isn’t a safe bet, what should or shouldn’t survive, what gets insured and at what cost, then how is one to separate money from it all. It’s already in there.

My conclusion: climate change isn’t just messing with the weather anymore. It’s sitting alongside every financial decision, whether we notice it or not.

Turns out there’s actually a name for this whole space — Climate Finance.

Apparently, it isn’t just some fund somewhere for solar panels. It’s the entire financial ecosystem, deciding where and why the money should go vis-à-vis cutting emissions, investing in renewable energy, building energy-efficient industries, houses and so on.

Not only this, but it also decides how economies should help a farmer survive a bad monsoon, or make a coastal town less likely to be washed away, or just figuring out which businesses are actually built to outlast the vagaries of climate.

My next question was: how and when did the world start talking about climate finance?

The answer pointed out that it is not as new as one might believe it to be. Climate Finance has been three decades in the making, only just, very slowly.

The concept of climate finance was floated in the late 1980s. The world had realised there was a glaring problem of a climate crisis at hand that needed addressing.

It was at this time that the Brundtland Commission first pushed the idea of an international mechanism to finance environmental protection.

In 1990, the United Nations began formal negotiations for a global climate treaty.

Then, in 1992, at the Rio Earth Summit, 154 nations signed the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.

The goal was to keep greenhouse gases from reaching dangerous levels and set up some basic rules for how countries would work together on it.

The problem was, none of it was binding. So, it was bound to fail.

By the late ‘90s, it was clear that without binding rules, not much can be accomplished.

That’s what brought in the Kyoto Protocol; the idea being that developed countries, having gotten rich first by industrialising (and polluting the environment, thereby), owed the rest of the world something.

For the first time, emission targets were made binding but only on them.

United States, the largest economy at the time, never joined in.

By 2009, it was obvious the agreement was on its way to become another failure

In 2009, at the famously failed Copenhagen summit, rich countries decided to throw money at the problem instead — pledging $100 billion to help poorer countries cut emissions.

The Green Climate Fund was born out of this. This was, more or less, the birth of climate finance in its modern form.

By 2015, it was clear that one-size-fits-all rules weren’t working and everyone had missed the point that economies operated differently.

Then, at the Paris Agreement, the world changed its approach. It was decided that every country would set its own targets and update them over time.

With the whole approach based on flexibility, almost every nation signed it. Whether it was enforceable is a different question entirely depending on the country itself.

Since Paris, the world keeps reconvening to check how bad things have gotten and patch the finance mechanisms accordingly.

Countries have now agreed to pay for damage done already (the Loss and Damage Fund), and the old $100 billion investment target is being replaced with a much bigger one of $300 billion by 2035, with an eventual aim of $1.3 trillion a year.

Looking back at it all, one thing stands out: every policy phase had a matching financial phase to back it up.

When the rules changed, the ways of investing money changed to try to keep up and each time, it was so because the last version simply wasn’t enough.

One offhand question about ₹100 crore, and I ended up three decades deep into a slow, stumbling start of a story about how the world tries and fails, tries again only to fail again, but gets up yet again, to put a price on fixing the planet it broke.

Climate finance: modus operandi

While I continue to mull over the ironies that spring out from the question at hand, I cannot deviate from the original question I asked.

And that brings me to the next part. How does climate financing work?

To understand how climate finance works, it’s imperative to establish what problem of climate change is being addressed.

When we stop climate change from getting worse, we refer to it as mitigation. If it helps us survive the damage already done, it’s called adaptation.

And almost everything in climate finance falls under one of these two.

Mitigation is emission reduction before they happen, to prevent the climate from getting worse. Clean energy from the sun and wind, energy-efficient buildings, low-emission transport manufacturing, and forest plantations for carbon sinks are all helping to prevent the climate from getting worse.

Funding for such projects is mostly done by private investors and corporates, as they generate enough revenue to attract them.

The term “carbon pricing,” which refers to the process of literally placing a cost on pollution, is a crucial idea when funding mitigation projects.

There are two approaches to carbon pricing. Cap-and-trade, which sets a limit on the amount of pollution that can be produced and allows trade within that limit to prevent violations. A simple carbon tax, which would be a set price per ton without any trading.

These are accompanied by a third, more flexible tool known as carbon credits.

Carbon credit is the most criticized of the three because it is a voluntary offset market with no enforced cap.

Adaptation only becomes relevant when the harm caused by the climate crisis needs to be addressed.

Financing includes disaster infrastructure, water systems, coastal protection, resilient agriculture, and more.

Since these projects are not profitable, responsibility primarily lies with governments and multilateral organisations like the World Bank or Green Climate Fund for funding them.

The banking affair

While I was trying to understand the modus operandi of climate finance, a nagging question the 18-year-old banker in me asked: when did the Banks get involved?

After all, ants cannot be far behind when sweets are laid. Give a bank an opportunity or threaten it with sabotaging one, and it shows its game.

At the turn of the millennium, the world was scrambling to keep a check on the environmental crisis to stop it from unravelling into a disaster, but the banking industry seemed to be unbothered; the reason: because banks will be banks.

After all, the profits and revenues seemed unaffected by the whole climate change thing, at least, that is what it seemed for a while.

Then in 2003, whether out of genuine conscience, pressure from NGO’s, moral obligation or just pure PR, Banks jumped on the bandwagon of climate change and 10 major banks (Citigroup, Barclays, ABN AMRO and a few more) got together to adopt what was named the Equator Principles.

It was settled, as per this code, that before financing a big project (dams, mines, power plants), environmental and social risks will be checked.

The whole thing was a tick-box activity with no enforcement or repercussions for lack of implementation and therefore, an eyewash.

On paper, it made them appear responsible and silenced the critics/activists for some time.

By 2011, when governments and organisations started to tighten climate policy, banks started to feel the pinch.

What was once an asset suddenly threatened to become a liability, making collateral worth less, or worse, making an outstanding loan susceptible to default. For example, BP wrote off 17.5 billion in stranded asset value, rendering its lender vulnerable.

In 2015, the governor of the Bank of England declared in his speech that climate change had stopped being an ethical issue and was a serious financial threat; the dilemma for the industry became real.

Simultaneously, a body named the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures was established by the Financial Stability Board of the G20, and some countries that were part of this task force made climate disclosures mandatory for themselves.

As of today, over a hundred banks across the world have mandatory laws to cover most of the world’s project finance market.

What started off as a half-hearted display of effort grew into laws, and the situation today makes it mandatory for banks to work under stricter laws to mitigate risk for the financial industry and environment.

The halal bond

Sometimes it’s like going down a rabbit hole, and one question leads to another.

At this point, while I am trying to grasp the basics of Climate Finance, as a banker who knows that nearly a quarter of the world’s population banks in a system that caters to its religious beliefs, I get curious.

Have Islamic Banking policies and their outcomes been affected by the mandatory laws?

Did imbibing these laws still keep their banking system profitable?

Is Islamic banking as committed to climate change? And the answer is not a simple “yes” or “no”.

Islamic banks that were operating in the jurisdiction of the UK, Turkey or the rest of Europe did not get any relaxation or custom regulation and, like the rest of the banking industry, had to align themselves to the laws and disclosures mandated without any consideration for being structurally different.

A market already sparingly regulated in this region found itself having to weave an extra layer of compliance.

Since pushback was not an option, while facing a shortage of experts and general regulatory friction, they accepted the law of the land begrudgingly.

To give them the due, they resolved, whatever conflict that arose, from within and never took up this issue formally in the niche markets that they operated in.

Then in 2017 Malaysia stepped in. Aspiring to become a financial capital for the Islamic countries across, they issued the first green Sukuk-the halal form of green bond where profits were shared instead of interest paid.

In fact, they went a step ahead and did what nobody had done before in the industry.

The Malaysian government borrowed the idea of subsidising from countries like Singapore, in order to pay for external auditors, and by doing so became a pioneer in combining green finance and Islamic banking.

In 2018, Indonesia borrowed a page from the green sukuk storybook of Malaysia and soon overtook them in absolute numbers in terms of capital generated, in just over a year. Saudi Arabia, the biggest player in the Islamic banking scene, followed suit in 2019, with UAE and Bahrain in tow.

As of now, Qatar and Kuwait, two powerhouses of the Islamic financial world, are still to make significant inroads to amalgamate Islamic banking with the climate cause.

But surprisingly enough, poorer Islamic nations like Egypt and Jordan have found creative ways by leaning on institutions like AIIB and IFC to start green finance initiatives.

Support from these institutions has helped them mitigate financial risk while still staying committed to the initiatives.

What works  

1. Math: While Islamic banking constitutes merely 1.3–1.5% of global banking assets, it represents 8.2% of all syndicated sustainable loans, well surpassing its relative share.

2. Innovation: By combining a tried-and-true method (government-subsidised verification expenses) with an innovative structure, Malaysia created a novel financial instrument called the green sukuk, and that is an actual product invention rather than cloning what its European counterparts had developed.

3. Expansion: By early 2025, green sukuk issuance had surpassed $35 billion. By the end of 2026 alone, issuance is expected to cross $10–12 billion.

4. Internal Competition: Within the Islamic nations, actual competition exists among issuers like Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Malaysia, and Indonesia in the green sukuk market, with Indonesia now surpassing Malaysia in total funds raised.

This competition will only help in making climate finance more relevant and established in these countries in particular and rest of the Islamic nations in general.

5. Green Debt: In a single month of 2023, Saudi Arabia’s PIF issued a historic $5.5 billion of green debt, suggesting that they are now committed beyond doubt to green finance as sovereign wealth is being used to directly fund audited green securities, rather than just creating off-balance sheet solar projects.

6. Pitching In: Jordan, with the help of IFC issued green bond proving that even a smaller, non-Gulf economy was eager to tap this niche market by accessing international development funding which in itself is a real expansion of who can participate in climate finance instruments and not just who pays for renewables.

7. Religious Binding: What cannot be ignored is the internal drive for reform. The Fiqh Council’s 2019 ruling against fossil fuel investment made climate finance an ongoing, internal accountability mechanism. It is essentially forcing the business to resolve the conflicts within. This is a sign of nations attempting to regulate internally and not just act purely upon outside criticism.

What’s going against 

1. The Contradiction: Nothing can change the fact that fossil fuel economies exist as a paradox.

The organisations that are behind the “green sukuk” are funded by the very thing that green finance is trying to avoid i.e. fossil fuels. The same sovereigns that issue green sukuk get 70-80% of government revenue from hydrocarbons.

2. Religious Inconsistency: A 2019 ruling by the Fiqh Council that investing in fossil fuels is unethical under Islamic finance principles have put Gulf banks, that issue green sukuk and have links to fossil fuel investments at odds with their religious tenets.

3. The Label Conundrum: Roughly only one-third of Islamic sustainable sukuk are labelled as “green”, compared with about two-thirds of conventional sustainable bonds. This means Islamic finance is pushing a large part of funds through the less stringent but broader “sustainable” category, and not the stricter, climate-specific one.

4. Non- Obligatory Standard: Unlike the mandatory Taxonomy-linked Green Bond Standard of the EU, the principles of green sukuk are not mandatory. In fact, the frameworks (ICMA-based) are voluntary industry norms without legal implications.

5. Existing Subsidies: In the GCC, the region’s green transition outcomes have been undermined by government fossil fuel subsidies. Many of the same governments that are backing green sukuk are also funding the fossil fuel side, which stands in direct contradiction to their stated transition.

6. International Regulations: Islamic banks are required to follow international reporting frameworks (TCFD, GRI) that are not designed with Islamic finance structural differences in mind. This makes it challenging for Islamic Banks to emulate the lending practices of conventional banks, as they use different instruments.

7. Erratic Implementation: Wealthy nations like Kuwait and Qatar show little interest in green sukuk issuance, indicating that despite the lead taken up by countries like Malaysia, Indonesia, Saudi Arabia and the UAE, many countries that use Islamic banking are reluctant to pick up from the lead and take it forward from there.

Climate finance: the answer

Looking back at the rabbit hole I fell into, the pattern is hard to miss.

The world has been telling itself the same story for three decades. We set the rules & then watch them fail, throw money at the gap, and patch it up again.

Banks did the same, changing their policies; from being a spectator to start reluctantly by making superficial changes to eventually introducing real laws once their own balance sheets felt threatened. Ethics may have gotten them to the table, but it was the risk of losing money that eventually made them act.

The green sukuk surprised me more than anything else. It proved that a financial system based on different tenets and beliefs could still reinvent itself into something entirely new. It also showed how a paradox in banking exists, making what is labelled as “green” sit alongside an oil well.

Green Finance in Islamic banking is funded by the very thing it is meant to replace. That is not a flaw of Islamic finance per se. It is the irony of the whole business.

So, has greed suddenly started caring about the environment? Even with a basic understanding of climate finance, you understand that that is wishful thinking.

The arithmetic has changed, however. Climate change now decides what is safe, what is insured, and what is repaid, so it has already decided where some of the money goes. Caring, if it ever exists, will come later.

My ₹100 crore does not get to choose whether climate change is in the room. It only gets to decide whether or not to notice it.

 

The author is a banker by profession and is taking a career break to explore her creative side. She writes on diverse topics when she finds time as a full-time mother of twins.

Click to comment
To Top